Giving at the average Protestant church rose 1.24% this year while prices rose 3.7%, and at the median church giving did not move at all, according to a Lifeway Research phone survey of 1,004 Protestant pastors taken Sept. 8 to 30, 2026. It is the second year running: in 2025, offerings at the average church rose 2.1% while inflation rose 2.9%. A youth pastor, a children's ministry director or a mission trip leader feels that gap in the program budget, which is where shirts come from. The usual response is to shop for a cheaper shirt. The better response is to count the shirts.
A second and third shirt run reach no wear the first shirt cannot reach
A youth ministry that prints a camp shirt, a serve day shirt and a Sunday shirt buys three shirts per student to reach wears that one planned shirt reaches alone. Put both plans on one youth calendar: camp in June, a serve day each month from September through May, and one Sunday when students lead worship. That is eleven events, counting camp week as one.
Three single-event runs put three shirts in each student's drawer: the camp shirt for camp, the serve day shirt for nine serve days, the Sunday shirt for one Sunday. One planned order puts one shirt in the drawer and sends it to all eleven. A student who comes to everything gets eleven wears either way. A student who misses four serve days gets seven either way. Attendance changes the wears. It never changes the shirt count, which is three per student against one.
Many students already wear the camp shirt to a serve day, and that settles the question. The camp shirt could have gone to every event on the calendar. The serve day shirt and the Sunday shirt add no wear the camp shirt could not have reached. What they add is two shirts per student, two more designs, two more proofs and two more size collections from families.
Each day on that calendar gives the shirt one job, and one shirt does all of them. At June camp it marks the season. On a serve day in a neighbor's street it unifies a team the neighbors can recognize. On the student-led Sunday it carries a verse in front of the congregation. On every one of those days, a leader line on the back identifies leaders. Those are the jobs of Ministry T-Shirts, and none of them needs a second design.
The design follows whichever event carries the year. If camp carries it, the one order is the camp shirt: camp name, dates and the week's verse on the front, worn to the serve days and the Sunday that follow.
Every shirt one order does not print stays in the 11% program line
The money one planned order saves stays in the program line, the smallest major line in a church budget and the one shirts share with curriculum, supplies and event costs. Lifeway Research summarized a Faith Communities Today finance report in March 2025: program support and materials make up 11% of the average congregation's spending, behind staff salaries and benefits at 43% and buildings and operations at 26%.
The 11% line is under pressure this year. With giving at the average church up 1.24% against prices up 3.7%, the same line buys less than it did a year ago, and 25% of pastors in Lifeway Research's 2026 survey said giving was below what they had budgeted.
A ministry can price what one order frees from its own records: two shirts, times the roster, times the price per shirt on last year's invoice. Set that figure beside the year's youth program budget before deciding the blank is the place to save.
A cheaper blank trims the price of each shirt; one order removes two shirts out of every three.
A shirt worn from June camp to the May serve day needs sizes that lean larger, a durable blank and a leader line on the back
Sizes for a shirt worn from June to May lean larger than sizes for a one-week shirt. Students grow between camp and spring, and a shirt a size big gets worn while a shirt a size small stays in a drawer.
A cheaper blank works against a one-order plan. A shirt meant for a year of serve days goes through the wash from June camp to the May serve day, and a blank that has worn out by October sends the ministry back for a second run, the cost the one order exists to avoid. The saving belongs in the shirt count, not the fabric.
A leader line on the back does the work of a second shirt color. Leaders need to be found at camp, on a serve day and on a Sunday morning, and one word across the shoulders does that on the same shirt, in the same order, on the same proof. A second color for leaders would mean a second setup and a second size collection. Ministry Gear offers free design help, and every design is approved before anything prints, so the leader line is settled once, before camp, for the whole year.
Students who join after June camp are the strongest case against one order a year, and spares in the same run answer it
The strongest objection a youth pastor raises to one shirt order a year is the student who walks in on the first Sunday in September. Camp shirts went out in June, and that student has none. The three-run plan seems to handle it, since a September serve day run reaches everyone on the fall roster. Under one order, a September reorder looks like a second setup, a second proof and possibly a printer's order minimum for a handful of shirts, and one order turns into two.
The answer is in the roster and the June run. Collect sizes from the full year's roster, not the camp list: students who came last fall, and in churches that promote a grade in the fall, the students moving up from the children's ministry. Then add spares to the same run, set by how many students joined after camp last year, with sizes weighted toward the middle and larger end of the bell curve, since a newcomer's size is unknown and a big shirt still gets worn. Spares ride on the same design, the same setup and the same proof.
Spares cost less than the runs they replace. To illustrate, take a roster of 40 at camp and six students who join by spring. The three-run plan prints 40 camp shirts, then 46 serve day shirts and 46 Sunday shirts, 132 in all. One order with six spares prints 46 in June and nothing after. The newcomers are covered by six extra shirts instead of 92.
If newcomers outrun the spares, the reorder covers the newcomers, not every student a second time.
A one-time event with a handful of people needs no shirt at all
A single afternoon with a few volunteers gives a shirt one wear apiece, the weakest count on any ministry calendar. A ministry shirt does its job by being worn many times by many people, and a one-time event cannot supply either.
Three questions decide whether an event needs a shirt. Will most people who receive it wear it again after the event? Does the event need to identify leaders or a team in a crowd, with no simpler way to do it? Does the event mark a season the ministry wants people to remember? If all three answers are no, the money will do more ministry somewhere else in the program budget.
To illustrate, take a spring Saturday when eight volunteers help an older member of the church clear a yard. Nothing else on the calendar gathers those eight people as a team, so a new shirt has no next wear. Eight people in one yard are not a crowd, and everyone already knows who is leading. The season is already marked by the ministry's shirt for the year. Three answers, all no.
The better plan costs nothing in shirts. The volunteers wear last year's ministry shirt, or everyone agrees on one color, and the team still looks like a team. A printed card with the verse goes home in a pocket. The shirt money buys work gloves and lunch, which do the job that day actually has.
A one-time event with a large crowd, such as a community festival, can answer the leader question yes. The year's ministry shirt with a leader line on the back answers it, and the event still needs no new shirt.
Spares for the students who arrive in the fall cost a handful of shirts; a second run costs a shirt for every student on the roster.
Plan the order from the full year's roster before pricing the blank: one design for camp, the serve days and the student-led Sunday, sizes that lean larger, a leader line on the back and spares for the students who arrive in the fall. An afternoon with eight volunteers needs last year's shirt or a shared color, a verse card in a pocket, and gloves and lunch.
Further reading
- Lifeway Research, 2026 phone survey of 1,004 Protestant pastors on the economy and church giving, the primary source for the giving and inflation figures research.lifeway.com/2026/10/22/more-churches-feeling-economic-squeeze
- Lifeway Research, 2025 survey of pastors on the economy, showing giving trailed inflation the year before research.lifeway.com/2025/10/14/pastors-split-on-the-economys-impact-on-their-churches
- Lifeway Research summary of a Faith Communities Today finance report, the source for how congregations divide their spending, including program support and materials research.lifeway.com/2025/03/25/church-income-rising-but-still-trails-inflation